Skip to content
Journal On Tourism & Sustainability/JOURNAL ON TOURISM & SUSTAINABILITY/Article
Article recordVersion of recordOpen accessVol. 3 No. 1 (2019): JOURNAL ON TOURISM & SUSTAINABILITYMay 30, 2026DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.20464860

Which Way Now? Comparison of Marine Codes of Conduct for Sustainable Marine Wildlife Tourism in West Wales

As a specific area of niche tourism, sustainable marine wildlife tourism has experienced dramatic growth in recent years. This has resulted in a plethora of academic and non-academic literature, exploring and reinforcin…

  • Contributor 1
  • Contributor 2

Reader actions

Resolve identifiers and download the published files.

View DOIDownload PDF
Abstract
Reader HTML view for the published article record.

As a specific area of niche tourism, sustainable marine wildlife tourism has experienced dramatic growth in recent years. This has resulted in a plethora of academic and non-academic literature, exploring and reinforcing good practice. However, little consideration has been given to whether current advice given to those involved in the industry is consistent. The seas around West Wales support an incredibly rich and diverse range of marine species, most notably dolphins, seals and whales. Although a number of voluntary marine codes exist for local boat operators, it is unclear whether these correlate with advice given to operators further afield. Recognising that consistent standards are vital when dealing with migratory species, this paper explores, via a thematic analysis, differences in current marine wildlife tourism codes of conduct between Wales and other countries located along the migratory routes of Minke, Orca and Fin Whales. Results show a proliferation of codes, which has resulted in significant levels of contradiction. This paper will make recommendations about what might improve existing local, national and international codes of conduct for marine wildlife tour operators and critique issues associated with those recommendations. Keywords: Marine wildlife tourism, niche tourism, codes of conduct, West Wales

References
Publication output reuses the stored scholarly reference text rather than a second reference system.
  1. 1.ACCOBAMS (2008) A Review of Whale Watch Guidelines and Regulations Around the World. Published by ACCOBAMS.
  2. 2.ACCOBAMS (2016) Commercial Cetacean Watching Activities in the ACCOBAMS Atlantic Area. ACCOBAMS. Resolution 6.20.
  3. 3.AECO (2017) Arctic Wildlife Guidelines. Published by the Association of Arctic Expedition Cruise Operators. Available at: https://s3-eu-west- 1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline-documents/Arctic_Association-of-Arctic- Expedition-Cruise-Operators-Cetacean-Guidelines . pdf [Accessed 6 April 2019].
  4. 4.ASCOBANS (2017) Annual National Report United Kingdom. Available at: https://www.ascobans.org/en/document/2017-annual-national-report-united-kingdom [Accessed 16 February 2019].
  5. 5.Breen, P., Brown, S., Reid, D. and Rogan, E. (2016). Modelling Cetacean Distribution and Mapping Overlap with Fisheries in the Northeast Atlantic. Ocean & Coastal Management, 134, pp.140-149.
  6. 6.Canaries Government (2002) Canary Islands Whale Watching Regulations. Available at: https://s3-euwest1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guidelinedocuments/Spain_Canary- Islands-Translated-summary-of-regulations-Spanish-German-English . pdf [Accessed 15
  7. 7.Ceredigion County Council (2010) Ceredigion Marine Code. Available from: http://www.cardiganbaysac.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/04/ceredigion-marine- code-2010 . pdf [Accessed 12 January 2019].
  8. 8.Ceredigion County Council (2019) Ceredigion Water Users Marine Code of Conduct. Available at: http://www.cardiganbaysac.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2019/02/190129- Ceredigion-Marine-Code-Conduct-Panelfinal pdf [Accessed 20 April 2019]. Ceredigion County Council (no date) Commercial Passenger Boat Code Prepared for Harbours Operating Within the Cardigan Bay Candidate SAC. Available from: http://www.ukmarinesac.org.uk/activities/ports/ph14.htm Accessed 11 February 2019
  9. 9.Cisneros-Montemayor, A., Sumaila, U., Kaschner, K. and Pauly, D. (2010) The Global Potential for Whale Watching. Marine Policy, 34(6), pp.1273-1278.
  10. 10.Cressey, D. (2014). Ecotourism Rise Hits Whales. Nature, 512 (7515), pp.358-358. Foote, A., Vilstrup, J., De Stephanis, R., Verborgh, P., Abel Nielsen, S., Deaville, R., Kleivane, L., Martin, V., Miller, P., Øien, N., Perez-Gil, M., Rasmussen, M., Reid, R., Robertsen, K., Rogan, E., Simila, T., Tejedor, M., Vester, H., Vikingsson, G.., Willerslev, E., Gilbert, M. and Piertney, S. (2011) Genetic Differentiation Among North Atlantic Killer Whale Populations. Molecular Ecology, 20(3), pp.629– 641.
  11. 11.Forney, K. and Wade, P. (2007) Worldwide Distribution and Abundance of Killer Whales. In: J. Estes (ed) Whales, Whaling and Ecosystems. University of California Press, pp 25.
  12. 12.Garrod, B., Fennel, D. (2004) An Analysis of Whalewatching Codes of Conduct. Annals of Tourism Research, 31(2), pp334-352.
  13. 13.Gjerdalen, G. & Williams, P.W. (2000). An Evaluation of the Utility of a Whale Watching Code of Conduct. Tourism & Recreation Research. 25 (2), pp 27-36.
  14. 14.Government of France (2017) Charter for Responsible Marine Mammal Observation (in French). Available at: https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline- documents/Reunion-2017mep-bat. pdf [Accessed 15 February 2019].
  15. 15.Government of Ireland (2005) Marine Notice No 15 of 2005. Guidelines for Correct Procedures When Encountering Whales and Dolphins in Irish Coastal Waters. Available at: https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline- 58 documents/Ireland_Marine-Notice-No-15-of-2005_Guidelines-for-correct-procedures- when-encountring-whales-and-dolphins . pdf [Accessed 15 January 2019].
  16. 16.Government of Portugal (2006) Regulations and Guidelines for Whale Watching in WatersUnder Portuguese Jurisdiction. Available at: https://s3- euwest1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline-documents/Portugal_2018- Summary-of-whale-and-dolphin-watching-guidelines-for-areas-under-Portuguese- Jurisdiction-English .pdf [Accessed 12 April 2019].
  17. 17.Government of Spain (2008) Spanish Decree for the Protection of Cetaceans 2008 (in Spanish). Available at: https://s3-eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline- documents/Spain_Decree-1727_2007_Protection-of-Cetaceans-in-relation-to-Tourism . pdf [Accessed 15 February 2019].
  18. 18.Greiner, R., Young, M.D., McDonald, A.D., Brooks, M. (2000) Incentive instruments for the sustainable use of marine resources. Ocean & coastal Management, 43, pp 29-50.
  19. 19.Hannam, K. & Knox, D. (2005). Discourse Analysis in Tourism Research: A Critical Perspective. Tourism Recreation Research, 30(2), 23-30. Hammond, P., Berggren, P., Benke, H., Borchers, D., Collet, A., Heide-Jorgensen, M. and Oien,
  20. 20.N. (2002) Abundance of Harbour Porpoise and Other Cetacenas in the North Sea and Adjacent Waters. Journal of Applied Ecology, 39, pp361-376. Hammond, P., Macleod, K., Berggren, P., Borchers, D., Burt, L., Cañadas, A., Desportes, G., Donovan, G., Gilles, A., Gillespie, D., Gordon, J., Hiby, L., Kuklik, I., Leaper, R., Lehnert, K., Leopold, M., Lovell, P., Øien, N., Paxton, C., Ridoux, V., Rogan, E., Samarra, F., Scheidat, M., Sequeira, M., Siebert, U., Skov, H., Swift, R., Tasker, M., Teilmann, J., Van
  21. 21.Canneyt, O. and Vázquez, J. (2013). Cetacean Abundance and Distribution in European Atlantic Shelf Waters to Inform Conservation and Management. Biological Conservation, 164, pp.107-122.
  22. 22.Hammond, P., Macleod, K., Gillespie, D., Swift, R., Winship, A., Burt, M. and Rogan E. (2007) Cetacean Offshore Distribution and Abundance in the European Atlantic (CODA). Published by the Sea Mammal Research Unit, University of St Andrews, Fife.
  23. 23.Icewhale (2015) Responsible Whale Watching. Available at: http://icewhale.is/code-of- conduct / [Accessed 2 February 2019].
  24. 24.IFAW (2009) Whale Watching Worldwide Tourism Numbers, Expenditures and Expanding Economic Benefits. International Fund for Animal Welfare.
  25. 25.Inman, A., Brooker, E., Dolman, S., McCann, R. and Wilson, A. (2016) The Use of Marine Wildlife-Watching Codes and their Role in Managing Activities within Marine Protected Areas in Scotland. Ocean & Coastal Management, 132, pp1-11.
  26. 26.IWC (1996) International Whaling Commission Guidelines. International Whaling Commission.
  27. 27.IWC (2013) Report of the Intersessional Working Group on Guiding Principles Development. International Whaling Commission.
  28. 28.IWC (2018) Whale Watching Strategic Plan 2018-2024. International Whaling Commission.
  29. 29.JNCC (1) (2013) Third Report by the United Kingdom under Article 17 on the Implementation of the Directive from January 2007 to December 2012 Conservation Status Assessment for S2027 Minke Whale (Balaenoptera Acutorostrata). Joint Nature Conservancy Council.
  30. 30.JNCC(2) (2013) Third Report by the United Kingdom under Article 17 on the implementation of the Directive from January 2007 to December 2012 Conservation Status Assessment for S2027 Killer Whale (Orcinus Orca). Joint Nature Conservancy Council.
  31. 31.JNCC(3) (2013) Third Report by the United Kingdom under Article 17 on the Implementation of the Directive from January 2007 to December 2012 Conservation Status Assessment for S2621 Fin whale (Balaenoptera Physalus). Joint Nature Conservancy Council.
  32. 32.Marino, L., Gulland, F. and Parsons, E. (2012). Protecting Wild Dolphins and Whales: Current
  33. 33.Crises, Strategies, and Future Projections. Journal of Marine Biology, 2012, pp.1-2. 59
  34. 34.MMC (2019) The Economics of Marine Mammals. Published by the Marine Mammal Commission.
  35. 35.Natural England (2017) Marine Recreation Evidence Briefing: Wildlife Watching. Available at: http://publications.naturalengland.org.uk/file/6514110136582144 16 February 2019 Natural Resources Wales (No date) Seawise Code. Natural Resources Wales. Available at: https://cdn.naturalresources.wales/media/3513/sea-wise-code.pdf 16 February 2019 New, L., Hall, A., Harcourt, R., Kaufman, G., Parsons, E., Pearson, H., Cosentino, A. and Schick,
  36. 36.R. (2015). The Modelling and Assessment of Whale-Watching Impacts. Ocean & Coastal Management, 115, pp.10-16.
  37. 37.Norwhale (2017) Norway National Guidelines for Whale Watching. Available at: https://s3- eu-west-1.amazonaws.com/wwhandbook/guideline- documents/NORWHALE.Brosjyre2017 . pdf [Accessed16 February 2019].
  38. 38.Parsons, E. (2012) The Negative Impacts of Whale-Watching. Journal of Marine Biology, pp.1- 9. Pembrokeshire Coastal Forum (no date) Pembrokeshire Marine Code. Available from: https://www.pembrokeshiremarinecode.org.uk/code-of-conduct 10 January 2019.
  39. 39.Ramseyisland.co.uk (2019) Boat Trips. Available at: https://www.ramseyisland.co.uk/boat- trips/whale-dolphin-watch / [Accessed 16 April 2019].
  40. 40.Reid, J., Evans, P. and Northridge, S. (2003) Atlas of Cetacean Distribution in North-West European Waters. Published by JNCC. Risch, D., Castellote, M., Clark, C., Davis, G., Dugan, P., Hodge, L., Kumar, A., Lucke, K., Mellinger, D., Nieukirk, S., Popescu, C., Ramp, C., Read, A., Rice, A., Silva, M., Siebert,
  41. 41.U., Stafford, K., Verdaat, H. and Van Parijs, S. (2014). Seasonal Migrations of North Atlantic Minke Whales: Novel Insights from Large-Scale Passive Acoustic Monitoring Networks. Movement Ecology, 2(1), p.24.
  42. 42.Ryan, C., Bolin, V., Shirra, L., Garrard, P., Putsey, J., Vines, J. and Hartny-Mills, L. (2018) The Development and Value of Whale-Watch Tourism in the West of Scotland. Tourism in Marine Environments, 13(1) pp 17-24.
  43. 43.Scottish Natural Heritage (2017) The Scottish Marine Wildlife Watching Code. Available at: https://www.nature.scot/sites/default/files/2017-06/Publication%202017%20- %20The%20Scottish%20Marine%20Wildlife%20Watching%20Code%20SMWWC%20- %20Part%201%20-%20April%202017%20%28A2263518%29 . pdf 16 April 2019.
  44. 44.Scottish Wildlife and Adventure Tourism Association (2010) Watching Wildlife by Boat. Published by the Scottish Wildlife and Adventure Tourism Association. Available at: http://wild-scotland.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/Watching-Wildlife-by-Boat- Apr-07-lo-res . pdf [Accessed 2 January 2019]. Sea Watch Foundation (no date) Marine Code of Conduct. Published by the Sea Watch Foundation. Available at: http://www.seawatchfoundation.org.uk/marine-code-of- conduct / [Accessed 10 January 2019].
  45. 45.Stdavids.gov.uk (2019) St Davids City Council. Available at: http://stdavids.gov.uk /# [Accessed16 April 2019].
  46. 46.Trave, C., Brunnschweiler, J., Sheaves, M., Diedrich. A., Barnett, A. (2017) Are We Killing them with Kindness? Evaluation of Sustainable Marine Wildlife Tourism. Biological Conservation, 209, pp 211-222.
  47. 47.Tripadvisor.co.uk (2019) St Davids Activities. Available at: https://www.tripadvisor.co.uk/Attractions-g552051-Activities-c61-t188- St_Davids_St_Davids_Peninsula_Pembrokeshire_Wales.html [Accessed 16 April 2019]. Van Waerebeek, K., André, M., Sequeira, M., Martin, D., Robineau, D., Collet, A., Papastavrou,
  48. 48.V. and Ndiyaye, E. (1999) Spatial and Temporal Distribution of the Minke Whale Balaenoptera Acutorostrata in the Southern Northeast Atlantic Ocean and the Mediterranean Sea, with Reference to Stock Identity. Journal of Cetacean Research Management, 1, pp223–237. 60
  49. 49.Visit Britain (2019) The GB Tourist 2017 Annual Report. Published by Visit England, Visit Scotland and Visit Wales. Available at: https://gov.wales/sites/default/files/statistics- and-research/2019-03/the-great-britain-tourist-statistics-2017 . pdf [Accessed16 April 2019].
  50. 50.Walker R (2018) Evaluating Marine Mammal Watching Legislation, Regulations and Codes of Conduct. Published by the Churchill Fellowship. Available at: https://www.wcmt.org.uk/sites/default/files/report- documents/Walker%20R%20report%202018%20Final_0 . pdf [Accessed 16 April 2019].
  51. 51.Walker, K. and Weiler, B. (2017) A New Model for Guide Training and Transformative Outcomes: A Case Study in Sustainable Marine-Wildlife Ecotourism. Journal of Ecotourism,16(3), pp269-290.
  52. 52.Walters, T. (2016) Using Thematic Analysis in Tourism Research. Tourism Analysis, 21(1), pp. 107-116.
  53. 53.WCA (2019) Global Best Practice Guidelines 2019. Published by the World Cetacean Alliance. Available at: http://worldcetaceanalliance.org/global-guidelines 22 February 2019]. WISE (no date) The UK National Training Scheme for Minimising Disturbance to Marine Wildlife. Available at: https://www.wisescheme.org / [Accessed 10 January 2019].
  54. 54.WWF (2019) Our Work. Available at: https://wwf.panda.org/our_work/wildlife/profiles/mammals/whales_dolphins/minke / [Accessed 16 January 2019]. Contributors: Contributors: Dr Jeanette Reis, Senior Lecturer in Tourism Contributors: Contributors: at Cardiff Metropolitan University, Wales, UK; Dr Emmet McLoughlin, Lecturer in Tourism at Cardiff Metropolitan University, Wales, UK. Correspondin Corresponding Author: Correspondin Correspondin g Author: g Author: Dr Jeanette Reis. Email: g Author: JReis@cardiffmet.ac.uk 61